Some White House officials tried to remove Karine Jean-Pierre from her role as Press Secretary. Here are the key points:
- Jean-Pierre’s hiring was based on her race and gender, not her performance, according to critics
- Officials wanted to find a “graceful exit” to replace her due to struggles answering questions
- Jean-Pierre reads word-for-word from preparednotes instead of speaking freely
Does the Press Secretary have what it takes to represent the President? Let’s take a closer look.
White House Insiders Wanted New Spokesperson
According to a report in the New York Post newspaper, some top White House advisors secretly tried to get Karine Jean-Pierre removed from her position as Press Secretary. They complained that Jean-Pierre does not seem to fully understand the issues she is asked about. Instead of explaining things in her own words, she reads prepared statements directly from her briefing binder.
One anonymous source said Jean-Pierre “reads the binder word-for-word” during press conferences and “thinks she’s doing an amazing job.” This same source told the Post that White House officials wanted to find Jean-Pierre “a graceful exit” by transferring her to a different role highlighting “diversity.”
However, top advisors Anita Dunn and Jeff Zients dismissed these claims as “nonsense” when asked by reporters.
Criticism of Jean-Pierre’s Performance
Several political commentators have criticized Jean-Pierre’s speaking style and abilities as Press Secretary. Joe Concha, a media reporter who was interviewed on Fox News, claimed Jean-Pierre’s position was “clearly a job awarded not based on performance but based on merit” referring to her race and gender.
He contrasted her with her predecessor Jen Psaki, saying Psaki could “think on her feet” while Jean-Pierre relies heavily on reading pre-written notes from her briefing materials. Concha said it is “sad to watch” Jean-Pierre struggle with unscripted questioning.
Defending Against Claims of Incompetence
Supporters of Jean-Pierre argue that she is unfairly criticized due to her identity as a Black, gay woman. They say she has been effective at calmly handling hostile questions from conservative media outlets.
Jean-Pierre herself has pushed back on allegations about her competence. In a recent interview, she stated: “I am not going to be fazed by any of this…I’ll just keep doing my job.”
She says becoming the first Black, openly LGBTQ+ person to hold the Press Secretary role is “amazing” and “not something I take lightly.” Jean-Pierre maintains she is qualified and prepared to serve as the President’s spokesperson.
Future of the White House Press Operation
With the 2024 presidential election season ramping up, all eyes will be on Jean-Pierre and how she handles the White House press briefing room.
Critics question whether she has the communications skills and policy knowledge to effectively promote the administration’s agenda and respond to pointed questioning from journalists.
Only time will tell if Jean-Pierre can quiet her detractors through her on-camera performance – or if the White House will seek new leadership for this very public role. How do you think she has done so far as Press Secretary?
* * *
Photo credit: AI
